AFW Safety

A Culture of Professionalism

Are You Landing for Safety or Comfort?

As pilots we all strive for passenger accolades after a smooth-as-glass landing, but is it the best landing?

I love to do pattern work, even after decades of flying, and working for a smooth landing.  While it can be rewarding and offers great training, it does come with some safety issues.   While Aircraft Flight Manuals (AFM/POH) for light aircraft don’t make specific mention of a firm landing without much float, generally all turbine Operating and Flight Manuals have a specific reference.  This reference is not always easy to find, but it is there.  The manufacturers’ note that their landing performance data does NOT include much float. In fact, they encourage a landing for safety – not comfort.   

Jim Dell, former AFW Safety Officer and frequent Command Pilot, recently sent me information on this topic and I thought it would be perfect subject for our AFW team.  I have written before on one of my favorite safety topics – Stabilized Approaches – and this is a fitting follow-up topic.

Let’s say you arrive a bit fast at 50 feet AGL and you have your friends in the plane with you. After some turbulence during your flight, you want to give them a smooth-as-silk landing.  As you approach a few feet above the runway, you utilize ground effect to make that landing so smooth they won’t know when you exactly reconnected with Mother Earth.   As you glide in ground effect, you see the runway passing beneath you while the runway markers on the sides indicate decreasing runway ahead of you.   You might even remember the old pilot saying, “The two most worthless items for a pilot are fuel on the ground, and runway behind you.”  You might also note the slight tailwind you have or the downward sloping runway ahead.  Suddenly, you are nearing the end of the runway. 

You contact the runway and work to slow down the plane while applying more brakes than usual. When you first apply the small brakes we have on planes, it takes some time for the plane to slow down from touch down speed to a full stop.  For reference, in the Beechcraft Premier I, it takes 80% of your landing distance to slowdown to 50% of you landing speed.  This is probably a good reference for other aircraft as well.

Analysis of recorded data on some aircraft indicates that pilots are striving for comfort at the expense of using the available runway for landing – “the runway behind you”.  In some cases, pilots aren’t touching down until between 2,000 – 3,000 feet down the runway.  That may be fine with extremely long runways, but isn’t good practice and could lead to miscalculations on shorter runways.

Aircraft landing performance is determined by being at Vref (1.2-1.3 times stall speed in landing configuration) at 50 feet AGL, power to idle and continuing at 3 degrees until touchdown, brake application after nosewheel contact (tricycle gear) and application of other life dump devices (spoilers, lift dump, thrust reversers).  While there are differences between various aircraft, this is the gist on how landing performance is determined.

I do love to have a glass-smooth landing; however, I strive to make precision touchdowns to Commercial/ATP pilot standards the vast majority of the time.  I’m always ready for a brake failure, perhaps since I’ve had them, and never speed up to the end of the runway or turn fast unto a taxiway.   I prefer safe landings over comfort landings.   Boeing and Embraer also produced a nice video on the topic: No Landing is Routine – Brake for Safety, Not for Comfort!

Article by Rich Pickett, AFW Safety Officer


If you have any specific questions about safety operations, please reach out to our safety team below.


Bruce Poulton, AFW Safety Officer
[email protected]

Alexios Stavropoulos, AFW Safety Officer
Bruce[email protected]

General Safety Email
[email protected]

Share this Article:

Subscribe to get our best content in your inbox


More Safety Articles


July Safety Update

Passengers. ATC. Weather. Evil instructors. That little needle that’s pointing somewhere it shouldn’t. Stuff that demands your attention when you’d rather just be pre-flying, flying, or post-flying. We pilots are

Read More »

April 2023 Safety Report

Pleasant greetings to all.  I feel immensely privileged to be able to address you all and it is a position that I will never take lightly.  The process of Threat

Read More »
instrument panel inside small plane 

What is Hard IFR?

Winter is almost over (but not quite) and the weather is changing. Spring is a time of quickly developing weather systems and unpredictable weather. Not that long ago I sat

Read More »

Mountain Flying

Are you a mountain pilot?  You probably are even if you aren’t aware of it.  In most of Angel Flight West’s territory we encounter many, or even all, of the

Read More »

Declaring an Emergency

Gather a room full of pilots and ask them the following questions: How many of you have had an emergency while in flight? How many of you have declared an

Read More »

Density Altitude

All pilots learn about density altitude yet most pilots never experience the truly detrimental effect it can have.   Brian, a friend of mine, flying a Piper Cherokee 160 and carrying

Read More »

Non-Tower Airport Operations

Since there is a high likelihood that at least one airport on most missions is uncontrolled or non-towered, we’d like to share some thoughts on uncontrolled airport operations.  If you

Read More »

Required Reports

In the course of my activities as a Flight Instructor and Mission Orientation Pilot, I take some time to review various pilot reporting requirements.  One of the many things I’ve

Read More »

Be Prepared

Angel Flight West believes that we should share what we learn about our missions and the airports we visit so that we can learn from each other.  So, with that

Read More »

Personal Minimums

All pilots, especially those who are instrument rated (those that are licensed by the FAA to fly in instrument meteorological conditions – i.e. clouds), are familiar with the term ‘personal

Read More »

Passengers First

You may be aware that in 2008 there were three Angel Flight accidents with fatalities in other Angel Flight regions. To say this may be tempting fate, but to date

Read More »